***Pay attention, beanie makers!!!***
(Writing this as an adult male with a 21.5" head, and I wear them unfolded.)
After an absolutely ridiculous amount of searching, I finally found exactly what I was looking for!
The fit is fantastic: compact, close-fitting, and perfectly proportioned without excessive slouch or bulk most adult beanies have. Reminds me a bit of the Steve Zissou beanie from 'A Life Aquatic' that Bill Murray wears. It's incredibly comfortable, and the 100% cotton construction is a huge plus.
I've been searching for this particular combination of fit, comfort, and substantial fabric for ages, and this beanie finally checks every box.
Absolutely love it. Will be stocking up. Highly recommended!